heart shaped pages
professional appraisals for novels, stories, poetry and plays
Fiction feedback home How we help Our service How to submit sample critiques Reviewers Proofing and Editing FAQs Contact us Costs Resources

What are you writing?

Novels
Short Stories
Writing for children
Poetry
Plays

Decide how many critiques you’d like - see Costs

Then access the submission form from the pages above, from How to Submit or from here.

Once you’ve completed the form, click on submit. You’re then asked to attach your work. Easy!

We then send you an electronic invoice, usually within 24 hours. You pay securely by credit or debit card, or by PayPal. If you’d rather post a cheque, that’s fine. The form gives you this opportunity.

We aim to return reviews of work under 15,000 words within 3 weeks.

If you’d rather submit your work by post, please see postal submissions.

12% discount for all repeat customers within 6 months

“ I am really grateful (and pleased!) with both appraisals and feel I have more than had my money's worth. Both reviewers have taken the time to thoroughly read my novel extract and comment on several areas, not just one or two, that either impressed them or they felt could be tweaked. I'm very, very happy and will definitely be recommending Fiction Feedback to my writer friends” ~ RB

How we help

We offer independent feedback on creative writing. We believe we’re unique in offering a number of critiques of your work; you're not limited to just one. Each critique comes from an individual reviewer, written independently.

We use our reviewing skills to:

• broadly analyse your writing
• highlight the strengths
• point up any major flaws
• suggest improvements, where required
• judge whether we think it's of publishable standard

Unlike your family and friends, we are objective.

Unlike a writers' circle, you never meet us, so you don't need to feel shy. Our critiques cannot be influenced by whether we like you or not!

Unlike writers' websites, we are focused on you and your writing. Our critiques aren't provided to show off our own writing, or to gain credits, or to sell other services.

Unlike some critique services, our critiques are professional, well-considered and in sufficient depth to be really useful.

Unlike many consultancy services, we are not expensive.

Unlike any other critique service that we know of, we offer multiple reviews.

We are
• a panel of reviewers who know good writing when we read it;
• skilled at spotting strengths and weaknesses in plot, character, viewpoint, style, dialogue and grammar;
• excellent at written English;
• enthusiastic in our enjoyment of the written word;
• possessed of keen critical faculties;
• proficient reviewers whose aim is always to help and to build;
• affordable.

How it works
One, two or more of our reviewers reads an extract of your novel or your other writing and each provides a written critique and completes a checklist of points.

Having critiques from two reviewers or more is a good idea – more than one opinion is always valuable. Overlapping views are reassuring, while different reviewers almost always pick up different points too. The fee is on a gently sliding scale; you pay far less than twice the cost of one critique for two.

For novel extracts and short stories over 2,000 words, prices start at just £65; two reviews cost £85.

Publication for two Fiction Feedback customers
First, congratulations to Molly Hopkins, whose hilarious and very engaging debut novel, It Happened in Paris, is now on sale. Published by Sphere, it tells the story of Evie, a madcap heroine who finds herself in charge of a coach tour to Paris. Given that Evie has great difficulty taking charge of anything, from credit cards to her sister’s children, we’re in for a rollercoaster ride…
Visit It Happened in Paris

Congratulations also go to David James, whose novel Confessions of Becky Sharp provides a scintillating, saucy prequel and sequel to William Thackeray’s Vanity Fair. Intrigue, schemes and scandal – it’s a dashing romp, and satisfyingly faithful to the character of Becky Sharp, everyone’s favourite adventuress.

Published by Vanguard Press.
Visit Confessions of Becky Sharp